Old John's Diner Menu (Update 2025)

Old John's Diner is a cozy comfort food spot located at 148 W 67th St in New York, offering a mix of diner classics and cocktails. With a range of vegetarian options and a focus on quality food and quick service, this diner is perfect for breakfast, brunch, or dinner. Customers rave about dishes like deviled eggs, turkey club, and mac and cheese, praising the homemade onion rings and generous portion sizes. The atmosphere is described as a cute old New York diner, perfect for a casual dining experience with friends or family. Despite limited espresso drinks currently due to renovations, Old John's Diner remains a neighborhood favorite with a good variety of food and accommodating service. Whether you're craving a classic breakfast dish or a comforting dinner, Old John's Diner is worth a visit for its delicious fare and welcoming ambiance.

Breakfast Sandwiches

Lox Sandwich

Scrambled eggs, gravlax, cream cheese, red onion, tomato, on a brioche roll

$14.00

Mexican Sandwich

Scrambled eggs, Mozzarella, avocado, sausage, brioche roll.

$12.00

The Kathy

Scrambled eggs, bacon, cheese, on a homemade biscuit.

$12.00

Bacon Egg And Cheese Sandwich

On a brioche roll.

$12.00

Granola & Yogurt

Served with berries.

$12.00

Oatmeal

Served with cinnamon, banana, raisins and maple syrup.

$10.00

Oatmeal (No Fruit)

$8.00

Healthy Start

Waffles, Pancakes & More

Buttermilk Pancakes

$14.00

Warm Apple Cinnamon Pancakes

$17.00

Classic Waffle

$14.00

Challah French Toast

Served with maple syrup and butter

$14.00

Stuffed French Toast

Challah bread stuffed with mascarpone cheese, cream cheese, raspberries, and served with caramel sauce, and strawberries

$20.00

Potato Latkes

With gravlax, two fried eggs, arugula, lemon vinaigrette.

$18.00

Eggs Your Style

Served with potatoes and toast.

$13.00

Shakshuka

Two eggs baked in tomato sauce, toast on the side.

$19.00

Burrito

Scrambled eggs, Mexican chorizo, black beans, Chihuahua cheese, cilantro and onion wrapped in a flour tortilla, served with pico de gallo and home fries.

$15.00

Huevos Rancheros

Two sunny side up eggs, salsa verde, black beans, crema, pickled onions, queso fresco, on crispy corn tortillas.

$16.00

Avocado Toast

Two poached eggs, paprika and red pepper flakes on sourdough toast, guacamole, watermelon radish, tomato, arugula, lemon vinaigrette, home fries.

$17.00

Chilaquiles Verdes

Crispy corn tortillas in green tomatillo, two sunny-side up eggs, avocado, queso fresco, crema.

$15.00

Chilaquiles Rojos

Crispy corn tortillas in choice of green tomatillo or guajillo-tomato salsa, two sunny-side up eggs, avocado, queso fresco, crema.

$15.00

Steak And Eggs

Sirloin steak, two eggs any style, potatoes.

$25.00

Frittata

Ham, potatoes, onions, grated Parmesan, served with toast.

$17.00

Frittata Florentine (Copy)

Spinach-Feta, potatoes, onions, grated Parmesan, served with toast

$18.00

Eggs Your Way

Omelettes

Goat Cheese Omelette

With roasted asparagus, and herbs. Served with potatoes & toast.

$17.00

Fresh Mozarella Omelette

Arugula, lemon vinaigrette, roasted cherry tomatoes on top. Served with potatoes & toast

$16.00

Western Omelette

Ham, pepper, onions. Served with potatoes and toast.

$16.00

Spinach Mushroom Omelette

With melted gruyere. Served with potatoes and toast.

$17.00

Deviled Eggs

Classic style topped with crispy bacon

$8.00

Mac & Cheese

cheese Mac and Cheese, panko crumbs.

$14.00

Mozzarella Sticks

Served with homemade marinara sauce

$12.00

Milans Meatballs

Fresh tomato sauce, parmesan and mozzarella.

$14.00

Takeout Appetizers

Takeout Sandwiches & Burgers

Old John's Burger

oz, Angus steak, white cheddar, onions, lettuce, tomatoes on a sesame bun

$16.00

Veggie Burger

Chickpea and quinoa patty, cheddar cheese, lettuce, tomato, onions, Old John's sauce, on a sesame bun

$14.00

Turkey Burger

Organic ground turkey, lettuce, tomato, Swiss cheese on a white roll

$15.00

Patty Melt

oz Angus beef, caramelized onions, russian dressing, and cheddar on grilled rye

$16.00

French Dip Sandwich

Hot roast beef, melted Swiss and mozzarella cheese, on ciabatta, beef au jus on the side

$17.00

Warm Chicken Club

Grilled chicken, mozzarella, sun-dried tomato aioli, bacon, avocado, grilled red onion, tomato, romaine, on a wheat toast

$16.00

Crispy Chicken Sandwich

Crispy buttermilk chicken breast, lettuce, tomato, sliced pickles, & chipotle mayo, on a brioche roll

$15.00

Turkey Club

Roasted turkey, BLT, guacamole, chipotle mayo, on a roasted ciabatta.

$16.00

Tuna Melt

Tuna salad, NYS cheddar, on sourdough bread

$15.00

Blackened Fish Sandwich

Icelandic cod, homemade tartar sauce, lettuce, tomato, on a brioche roll

$18.00

Chicken Soup

Homemade broth, pulled chicken, kale, carrots, celery

$8.00

Matzo Ball Soup

Chicken consomme, matzo meal dumplings, celery, carrots, dill

$10.00

Soup Of The Day

Monday: Minestrone / Tuesday: Lentil Soup / Wednesday: Split Pea Soup / Thursday: Beef Barley Soup / Friday: Cream of Mushrooms / Saturday & Sunday: Beef Chili

$8.00

Cobb Salad

Romaine, baby arugula, blue cheese, cherry tomatoes, boiled egg, bacon, grilled chicken, homemade buttermilk ranch dressing.

$20.00

Greek Salad

Romaine, feta cheese, tomato, pickled red onion, cucumber, kalamata olives, pepperoncini, fried chickpeas, Greek dressing, homemade focaccia.

$15.00

Caesar Salad

Romaine, parmesan, croutons, Caesar dressing

$14.00

Takeout Soup & Salads

Takeout Entrees

Vegetarian Rigatoni

Broccoli pesto, mushrooms, peas, red onions, asparagus, Parmesan, ricotta.

$20.00

Fish & Chips

Tempura crispy cod, french fries, homemade tartar sauce on the side.

$26.00

Roasted Icelandic Cod

With mixed green vegetables, rice, and basil pesto sauce.

$24.00

Wild Salmon

With pastrami glaze, rice, asparagus, crispy shallots, lemon vinaigrette.

$26.00

Shrimp Scampi

Shrimp scampi served with spaghetti marinara, Parmesan cheese, homemade focaccia bread

$26.00

Rigatoni A La Vodka

Creamy marinara, vodka, Parmesan cheese, fresh basil.

$19.00

Pan Roasted Chicken

Organic crispy chicken, herbed butter, mashed potatoes, haricoverts and gravy.

$26.00

Spaghetti & Meatballs

Marinara sauce, Parmesan and burrata cheese, basil, homemade focaccia.

$24.00

My Momma's Meatloaf

Mashed potatoes, french beans, almonds, brown gravy

$23.00

Braised Short Rib

With brasato sauce, mashed potatoes, grilled broccolini, lemon vinaigrette, panko breadcrumbs, crispy shallots, hazelnuts

$26.00

Steak Frites

oz Prime New York Steak, sauce verte, french fries.

$32.00

Chicken Paillard

Grilled organic chicken breast, arugula, cherry tomatoes, pickled red onions, Parmesan, balsamic glaze

$28.00

Ham & Cheese Omelette

Ham, cheese, toast. Served with potatoes between :AM - PM, french fries after PM, and home fries ONLY for brunch and breakfast.

$16.00

Spinach & Mushroom Omelette

Fresh spinach, caramelized mushrooms, melted Gruyere, and toast. Served with potatoes between :AM - PM, french fries after PM, and home fries ONLY for brunch and breakfast.

$16.00

Steak & Eggs

Sirloin steak, two eggs any style. Served with potatoes between :AM - PM, french fries after PM, and home fries ONLY for brunch and breakfast.

$24.00

Western Omelette

Ham, peppers, onions, and toast. Served with potatoes between :AM - PM, french fries after PM, and home fries ONLY for brunch and breakfast.

$16.00

Challah French Toast

Served with maple syrup and butter

$13.00

Buttermilk Pancakes

Served with maple syrup and butter

$13.00

Takeout All Day Breakfast

Takeout Sides

French Fries

$5.00

Green Beans

$6.00

Sauted Spinach

$6.00

Broccollini

$6.00

House Salad

$6.00

Fresh Mozarella Omelette

Arugula, lemon vinaigrette, roasted cherry tomatoes on top. Served with potatoes & toast

$16.00

Ham & Cheese Omelette

Ham, cheese, toast. Served with potatoes between :AM - PM, french fries after PM, and home fries ONLY for brunch and breakfast.

$16.00

Western Omelette

Ham, peppers, onions, and toast. Served with potatoes between :AM - PM, french fries after PM, and home fries ONLY for brunch and breakfast.

$16.00

Goat Cheese Omelette

With roasted asparagus, and herbs. Served with potatoes & toast.

$17.00

Spinach & Mushroom Omelette

Fresh spinach, caramelized mushrooms, melted Gruyere, and toast. Served with potatoes between :AM - PM, french fries after PM, and home fries ONLY for brunch and breakfast.

$16.00

Brunch Omelettes

Brunch Sandwiches

Old John's Burger

oz, Angus steak, white cheddar, onions, lettuce, tomatoes on a sesame bun

$16.00

Classic BLT

$14.00

Grilled Cheese

$14.00

Warm Chicken Club

Grilled chicken, mozzarella, sun-dried tomato aioli, bacon, avocado, grilled red onion, tomato, romaine, on a wheat toast

$16.00

Turkey Club

Roasted turkey, BLT, guacamole, chipotle mayo, on a roasted ciabatta.

$16.00

Tuna Melt

Tuna salad, NYS cheddar, on sourdough bread

$15.00

Greek Salad

Romaine, feta cheese, tomato, pickled red onion, cucumber, kalamata olives, pepperoncini, fried chickpeas, Greek dressing, homemade focaccia.

$15.00

Caesar Salad

Romaine, parmesan, croutons, Caesar dressing

$14.00

Chicken Soup

$8.00

Brunch Soup & Salads

Brunch Sweet Start

Buttermilk Pancakes

Served with maple syrup and butter

$13.00

Classic Waffle

$14.00

Challah French Toast

Served with maple syrup and butter

$14.00

Granola & Yogurt

Served with berries.

$12.00

Brunch Granola & Yogurt

Brunch Specialties

Huevos Rancheros

Two sunny side up eggs, salsa verde, black beans, crema, pickled onions, queso fresco, on crispy corn tortillas.

$16.00

Avocado Toast

Two poached eggs, paprika and red pepper flakes on sourdough toast, guacamole, watermelon radish, tomato, arugula, lemon vinaigrette, home fries.

$17.00

Steak And Eggs

Sirloin steak, two eggs any style, potatoes.

$25.00

Potato Latkes

With gravlax, two fried eggs, arugula, lemon vinaigrette.

$18.00

Shakshuka

Two eggs baked in tomato sauce, toast on the side.

$19.00

Frittata

Ham, potatoes, onions, grated Parmesan, served with toast.

$17.00

Chilaquiles Rojos

Crispy corn tortillas in guajillo-tomato salsa, two sunny-side up eggs,avocado, queso fresco, crema.

$15.00

Chilaquiles Verdes

Crispy corn tortillas in green tomatillo, two sunny-side up eggs, avocado, queso fresco, crema.

$15.00

Stuffed French Toast

Challah bread stuffed with mascarpone cheese, cream cheese, raspberries, and served with caramel sauce, and strawberries

$20.00

Breakfast Burrito

$14.00

Burrito

Scrambled eggs, Mexican chorizo, black beans, Chihuahua cheese, cilantro and onion wrapped in a flour tortilla, served with pico de gallo and home fries.

$15.00

Fried Chicken And Waffles

$22.00

Frittata Florentine (Copy)

Spinach-Feta, potatoes, onions, grated Parmesan, served with toast

$18.00

Bacon Egg And Cheese Sandwich

On a brioche roll.

$12.00

The Kathy

Scrambled eggs, bacon, cheese, on a homemade biscuit.

$12.00

Mexican Sandwich

Scrambled eggs, Mozzarella, avocado, sausage, brioche roll.

$12.00

Lox Sandwich

Scrambled eggs, gravlax, cream cheese, red onion, tomato, on a brioche roll

$14.00

Brunch Egg Sandwiches

Brunch Entrees

Steak Frites

oz Prime New York Steak, sauce verte, french fries.

$32.00

Wild Salmon

With pastrami glaze, rice, asparagus, crispy shallots, lemon vinaigrette.

$26.00

My Momma's Meatloaf

Mashed potatoes, french beans, almonds, brown gravy

$23.00

Coke

$3.00

Diet Coke

$3.00

Sprite

$3.00

Root Beer

$3.00

Dr Brown Cream

$3.00

Pellegino

$9.00

Aqua Panna

$7.00

Small Orange Juice

$6.00

Large Orange Juice

$8.00

Iced Tea

$4.00

Ginger Ale

$3.00

Seltzer Water

$3.00

Lemonade

$4.00

Mint Lemonade

$4.00

Gls Milk

$3.00

Soft Drinks

Coffee

Americano

$4.00

Cappuccino

$4.00

Chai Latte

$6.00

Decaf House Coffee

$3.00

Flat White

$4.00

House Coffee

$3.00

Iced Americano

$5.00

Iced Capuccino

$5.00

Iced Chai Latte

$7.00

Iced Coffee

$4.00

Iced Latte

$5.00

Iced Mocha

$6.00

Latte

$4.00

Hot Matcha

$6.00

Iced Matcha

$6.00

Orange Espresso

$9.00

Tumeric Latte

$6.00

Vanilla Latte

$4.00

Strawberry Shortcake

Buttermilk biscuit, pistachio pastry cream, strawberry reduction, fresh strawberries, toasted chopped pistachios, chantilly whipped cream

$12.00

Black And White Tart

Filled with classic French pastry cream

$12.00

Warm Brownie

$12.00

Sweets

Cakes & Pies

Apple Pie

with salted caramel sauce

$9.00

Lemon Meringue Pie

$9.00

Carrot Cake

with cream cheese frosting and pecans

$9.00

New York Cheesecake

with berry compote

$9.00

-Layer Chocolate Cake

With chocolate ganache

$9.00

Classic Vanilla Milkshake

$9.00

Classic Chocolate Milkshake

$9.00

Malted Black & White Milkshake

$9.00

Vanilla Egg Cream

Milk, carbonated water & syrup

$6.00

Chocolate Egg Cream

Milk, carbonated water & syrup

$6.00

Milkshakes & Egg Creams